Filed under:

Why should we believe in hopeful stories?

What if there's another show with a quote: “9000 years of space and time and trust me some of them were unimportant, you could be one of them”?

By Satyam Ghimire | Date:

Last modified date:


Also available as a YouTube video.

Two empty chairs are having a conversation.

two empty chair
Two empty chairs in some desolate landscape

Chair A: The other day I read this quote from Doctor Who, you know, this sci-fi show, “900 years of space and time and I never met someone who wasn't important.” I saw it on Facebook.

Chair B: It's like that movie from the 1940s, It's a wonderful life.

Starring James Stewart?

Yeah, starring him. I love that film.

But I was thinking, should we be inspired? Like this is a human invention, not an universal truth. Like what if there's another show with a quote: “9000 years of space and time and trust me some of them were unimportant, you could be one of them.” How about that? Should we be demotivated then?

That’s an interesting question.

It’s just some writer wanting to spread hope. And why should we buy it? Why should they make a film with this character who thinks it would have been good if he was never born and then they show the world where he wasn't born and it was all bad and so he realizes that he actually mattered in making this world a better place? I mean, why not show that the world could have been good without him. That he was right to think that way, that he truly didn’t mattered much.

Well, then it won't sell. Do you think people would have loved if it had gone that way?

No, but likeness shouldn't have anything to do with the truth.

Okay, then what is the truth? Is it like you said, that some people’s life is not important?

I never said that. I was just wondering why we are bombarded with these so-called hopeful stories, I mean, yeah I get it, but shouldn't we at least acknowledge that there are two sides.

What good would that be? Spreading fear and discomfort?

What we have been doing is hiding this other side, pretending it doesn't exist, and then suddenly life hits our subject and he doesn't know what to do. His Gods have fallen. His world breaks down and he is confused. And slowly he starts to realize that he has been spoon fed with these happy stories, these quotes, and now he is very very angry.

Nothing is sadder than a young pessimist, have you heard this quote?

Mark Twain

And don't you agree with him?

I do, but feelings shouldn't come in the way of truth. The point of art should be to show unbiased truth, not hide and pretend some sides do not exist.

To comfort the disturbed and disturb the comfortable.

Exactly. And all they do is comfort the disturbed.

Well, there are more disturbed people. Have you watched this movie, Second hand lions?

Yes, and I know that monologue. That we should believe in these good things, not because they are true, but because they are the things worth believing in.

Then why don't you accept it?

These are all but human stories and don’t mean anything. I mean I can memorize the lesson and understand its reason, but would that comfort me in hard times? No, it wouldn't. Knowledge doesn’t save you from feelings.

Everyone knows that the world is a bad place and around every corner misery is conspiring to strike, so the job of an artist is to not succumb to sadness but provide a cure to this emptiness, to this depression.

It's from Midnight in Paris, right, Gertrude Stein says that to Owen Wilson?

Yes. And I agree with her. And have you watched Westworld.

No

Well, there is this monologue by Anthony Hopkins on the second episode, that although it was said in a different context, sort of fits here. He says, quote unquote The guests aren't looking for stories that tell them who they are, they already know who they are. They come here to find a glimpse of who they could be.

Well, what if who they could be isn't achievable? They were lied their whole life, filled with false hope. Then suddenly they realize they were stupid to have believed in these fairy tales, to have been played. Wouldn't that make them angry?

They might. So what?

What so what?

Yeah, what do you want me to do?

You, personally, nothing. But I wish more artists wouldn't shy away from acknowledging that there is another side.

If “it’s a wonderful life” instead showed that Stewart's life really didn't matter, then you wouldn't even watch it yourself. You wouldn't even care.

I would watch it, but it won't be famous, so I wouldn't know about it.

No, you wouldn't watch it. How many such movies have you watched with this true view of the world, and not fairy tales?

Hmm… I need to think. Well…hmm…Blade runner 2049. Gosling didn't matter there. And that movie plot is exactly my point. He believes he is special from the beginning and suddenly he finds out he is not. And what does he do when he finds out? He chooses to die.

But his life did matter in the film, to make these father and daughter meet.

In the grand scheme of plot, yes, but what about his personal life?

Well his personal life is out of question here. His life mattered in some way. So the Doctor Who quote applies.

Then the character should just sit on a bench the whole film, and not just the whole film, but he should sit on that same bench his whole life, and he should sit there since he was born, and it’s all absurd even thinking about it.

Yes exactly, and still he might matter because he is sitting there. And you are complaining that this absurd film isn't getting made?

I get it, that the quote is right? But what if this person is a criminal?

Someone who has killed two people and is sentenced for 40 years in prison?

Yes, like that.

Well then that is Brooks and Red from The Shawshank Redemption. But they did make us feel, didn’t they?

Yes they did. But it’s only because it’s a movie and we got to know about them. There are thousands of Brooks around the world and do they all matter in some way?

They do, don’t you think that?

You’re right. I was only wondering can we be motivated by fiction? Should we surrender our thoughts against these hopeful stories when we know they are fake invention?

We should. We should choose light, we should walk towards it, even though we are deep in the cave.

It’s all about choice, isn’t it then? Fiction, real life stories, it’s all the same. Just because it happened to someone fictional or someone living in another city doesn’t mean the same thing would happen to you. It could be totally opposite in your case. So it’s all about choice in the end, isn’t it, what do you want to believe in? What do you want to look forward to? How do you want to amuse yourself?

Yes, but more than choice, it should be compulsory to amuse yourself with hope if you want to live. And you must live. You must live.






Share on social medias:


Read also:

Filed under:

Why do all Omelians not realize that an apple tree won't just suddenly turn sour and will grow thorns just because that child in the hole is removed? That their water won't just suddenly turn into poison just because the child is released?

By Satyam Ghimire || Date: 2026 October 14


Also available as a YouTube video.
walking away from omelas and iphone

The short story, 'The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas' has a sequel, well not official, since it was written by another writer named Isabel J Kim in 2024 and Ursula K Le Guin died in 2018 and so she couldn't comment anything. But the sequel is not just a typical fan fiction, it has won several awards like the first one and even has its own Wikipedia page. And there are so many other work inspired by the original story. You can read more about them on Jed Hartman's website. But today I am only going to talk about these two, the original by Le Guin and the solution proposed by J Kim. If you have read the original, then I assume you too were rooting for walking away, because that's the moral thing. I assume you think you would walk away too from Omelas.

But I don't think, and I know this isn't a new interpretation of the story, that the central theme was these decisions, these questions. Questions such as, "Omelas is immoral, don't you think?" "Walking away is the right thing to do, isn't it"? But first, do you know iPhone 18 is releasing? Or some cool laptop, or a new GPU architecture now with more number of cores, or an AI model that can solve Navier Stokes level math problems, or some EV cars that's even nicer and has better speakers than what was released 2 months ago? Omelas is a fictional city, a utopia of some sense. But you have to imagine the contents of Omelas yourself, as the narrator of the story says. You can add whatever to Omelas like iPhones and lipsticks and gaming laptops and gold chain, etcetera. All the things that are signs of a happy city, filled with happy people. ...continue reading...

Filed under:

Unfortunately, I tend to update CSS rather than writing anything new.

Date: 2026 April 11

Filed under:

It shouldn't make a difference to the Universe in sending an asteroid, or increasing the pride of some leaders, when you are 80, instead of doing it when you were 5.

Date: 2025 June 28

Filed under:

How can I stand with an ugly man and look in the mirror and meet my eyes and be proud?

Date: 2023 July 17

Filed under:

If someone lives in your house, in your room, and is the child of your very own parents, who do you think that will be? I don’t mean the body.

By Satyam Ghimire || Date: 2023 July 17


man looking at the sky

Two hundred million sperms raced for an egg, and somehow, it was you who came out. Just a little bit of tweaking from your parents could have changed that. Say if your parents had married a day earlier, or a day later. If your father had woken up one more morning for a walk and upon returning saw your mother shining like a goddess in the light coming through the window. Now consider the odds of the birth of the right ancestor and their whole life, odds ranging from something as miniscule as the same time of urination to something as big as marrying the right person. Something like Dr. Manhattan's quote from comics “The Watchmen” by Alan Moore. Thermodynamic miracles... events with odds against so astronomical they're effectively impossible, like oxygen spontaneously becoming gold.

I long to observe such a thing. And yet, in each human coupling, a thousand million sperm vie for a single egg. Multiply those odds by countless generations, against the odds of your ancestors being alive; meeting; siring this precise son; that exact daughter... Until your mother loves a man she has every reason to hate, and of that union, of the thousand million children competing for fertilization, it was you, only you, that emerged. To distill so specific a form from that chaos of improbability, like turning air to gold... that is the crowning unlikelihood. The thermodynamic miracle. But it's always going to be you. Only you. ...continue reading...

Forrest Gump sitting on a bench
Filed under:

I guess most people hate it because it got the best of both worlds: won several Oscars and made a lot of money. And in the same year, The Shawshank Redemption and Pulp Fiction were also released.


By Satyam Ghimire | Date: 2024 September 29

Also available as a YouTube video.